The FCC seeks public input on how it can change the rules that limit direct and indirect foreign ownership in media and telecommunications companies to reduce barriers to foreign sources of capital without compromising oversight of national security and other concerns.
At its October open meeting, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) announced a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) that considers ways to facilitate foreign investment in the telecommunications industry, including in broadcast media, a sector in which foreign ownership has been actively discouraged because of the potential for foreign influences on the content of broadcast transmissions. The NPRM does not explicitly propose changes to the “Team Telecom” process (i.e., the often protracted and intrusive Executive Branch review of foreign investment in the telecommunications industry for law enforcement and national security issues), but it does signal the FCC’s openness to changes that would reduce or eliminate barriers to foreign ownership without compromising national security, law enforcement, or other policy goals. Accordingly, we encourage industry to press for changes that would streamline costly, inefficient, and intrusive requirements and procedures that discourage foreign investment in broadcast and telecommunications entities. The filing date for comments and reply comments in response to this NPRM will be announced soon.
According to the FCC, a new approach to the process is necessary to “facilitate investment from new sources of capital at a time of growing need for capital investment in this important sector of our nation’s economy.” The proposed rules would alter the way that the FCC implements the Communications Act of 1934 requirement that allows the FCC to grant permission for licensed broadcasters and common carriers to exceed 25% indirect foreign ownership. The NPRM specifically proposes to allow broadcast licensees to request and receive approval for a controlling parent of the licensee to have up to 100% (equity and voting) foreign ownership, subject to an FCC public interest review. The NPRM also proposes to allow an approved controlling foreign investor to increase its ownership to 100% and to allow any approved noncontrolling foreign investor to increase its interest in the US parent to up to 49.99% in the future without requiring an additional FCC petition. Additionally, the proposed rules would make clear that licensees would not require approval of any noncontrolling foreign investor with an interest of 5% or less (or 10% or less in certain circumstances).
The NPRM proposes that broadcast licensees be afforded the benefits of a streamlined review process previously granted to common carriers but be held to the broadcast attribution criteria and thresholds for disclosure of the principal US and foreign owners, rather than the thresholds applicable to common carrier licensees. Under that approach, broadcast licensees asking to exceed the 25% indirect limit generally would not require approval or disclosure for foreign entities below 5% or nonvoting interests. All general partners and “noninsulated” limited partners and limited liability company (LLC) interests would be attributable, except for those limited partners and LLC interest holders that meet the insulation criteria and that certify that they are not materially involved in management or operations of the entity’s media interests.
Prompted by a recent case in which a party was compelled to seek FCC approval to exceed the 25% indirect ownership limit because it could not prove that foreign entities do not beneficially own or vote more than 25% of its shares, the NPRM also seeks public input on how foreign ownership should be determined and calculated, with an aim to provide some relief to widely held or publicly traded companies that may not have information on their shareholders’ identities. Among questions about other potential measures, the NPRM asks whether the FCC should accept information regarding shareholder street addresses, perhaps coupled with participation in the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation’s SEC-100 program (which provides monitoring of foreign-owned shares in separate accounts) as a proxy for determining shareholder citizenship.
Finally, the FCC seeks comment on any additional reforms that can further streamline the review of foreign ownership, while ensuring that important national security, law enforcement, trade policy, and other public policy goals continue to be met. This catch-all solicitation for ideas opens a valuable opportunity for parties to propose changes to the FCC’s common carrier foreign ownership process and/or the Team Telecom process.
This FCC proceeding will be an important one for entities interested in investing in the US broadcast and telecommunications sector. If adopted, the proposals in the NPRM could significantly lower the regulatory barriers for foreign investment in the broadcast industry and open new reforms of the Team Telecom review process. We encourage industry to file comments with the FCC to propose ways to streamline the FCC’s foreign ownership review procedures that currently discourage foreign investment in broadcast and telecommunications entities.
If you have any questions or would like more information on the issues discussed in this LawFlash, please contact any of the following Morgan Lewis lawyers: