This article examines the Supreme Court’s First Amendment incitement (Brandenburg v. Ohio) and school speech (Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District) standards as they apply to post-game rioting following college sporting events. The article uses the East Lansing, Michigan rioting that followed the 2013 Big Ten Football Championship as a case study and argues that public universities/colleges should be able to discipline students for speech at college sporting events that “can reasonably be regarded as encouraging violence or property destruction.”