WHAT AN EXECUTED APA SETTLES
A bilateral advance pricing agreement (APA) can establish an agreed transfer pricing method with tax authorities for multiple future years and, where appropriate, apply that method to earlier tax years, a step known as rollback. This agreement is binding on the taxpayer and the IRS.
Under Revenue Procedure 2015-41, if the taxpayer complies with the agreement, the IRS will not contest application of the agreed method to covered issues, subject to the procedure’s exceptions. If the covered issue is audited, the IRS examination function focuses on compliance and supporting calculations rather than reconsideration of the agreed method.[1]
That is a meaningful distinction from transfer pricing documentation, which supports the taxpayer’s position but does not bind the IRS. A bilateral APA also rests on a competent authority resolution between the United States and the treaty partner (an agreement reached by the officials each country designates to apply the treaty), rather than acceptance by the IRS alone.
Depending on the transaction and method, an APA can specify the covered transactions and years, the tested party, the profit measure or pricing range, and how the method will be applied. For illustration, consider a US distributor that repeatedly purchases goods from a related foreign manufacturer.
A bilateral APA could specify how the distributor’s return will be tested, the agreed operating margin range, and the adjustments required when results fall outside that range. The practical benefit is an agreed approach to recurring pricing questions, rather than a fresh debate over the method for each covered year.
TRANSACTIONS THAT CAN BE COVERED
The IRS’s annual APA statistics for 2025 illustrate the range of transactions and industries that can be covered. Services accounted for 53% of the transactions covered; sales of tangible property accounted for 28%; and the use of intangible property accounted for 17% (Table 1).[2]
Table 1. Transactions, industries, and methods in APAs executed by the IRS, 2025
|
Covered transactions (share of transactions covered) |
2025 |
|
Provision of services |
53% |
|
Sale of tangible property |
28% |
|
Use of intangible property |
17% |
|
All other transaction types |
2% |
|
Industry of the taxpayer (number of APAs executed) |
2025 |
|
Manufacturing |
22 |
|
Wholesale and retail trade |
32 |
|
Services |
28 |
|
Management |
16 |
|
Finance, insurance, and real estate |
8 |
|
All other industries |
4 |
WHEN AN APA IS WORTH EVALUATING
The threshold questions are whether recurring controversy exposure justifies the application and compliance effort, whether the arrangement is likely to remain relevant through the period of coverage, and whether the data, systems, and business teams can implement the negotiated terms.
A short-lived transaction, limited recurring exposure, or an imminent redesign of the operating model may weaken the business case for pursuing an APA. In those circumstances, the tax department should first assess whether the expected coverage would justify the effort.
WHAT THE PROCESS REQUIRES
Prefiling engagement with the IRS’s Advance Pricing and Mutual Agreement (APMA) program can help assess suitability and scope before a full request is prepared. Under the IRS’s internal procedures, APMA may recommend that the taxpayer proceed, provide more information, or consider another route to certainty. Prefiling review is therefore more than an administrative step.[3]
The application presents the factual record and proposed pricing analysis for review by both authorities. APMA evaluates the request and develops the US position for negotiations with the treaty partner’s competent authority. The taxpayer remains involved through information requests, factual presentations, and consideration of proposed terms.
If the competent authorities reach agreement and the taxpayer accepts it, the resolution is implemented through an APA between the taxpayer and the IRS.[4]
The treaty partner shapes that negotiation. In 2025, 35% of the bilateral APAs that APMA executed were with India; 25% were with Japan; and 11% were with Canada, while the applications filed during the year were more evenly spread across a wider group of treaty partners (Figure 1).[5]
Figure 1. US bilateral APAs by treaty partner, 2025
Tax departments should look to experience with the relevant treaty partner, rather than treat aggregate US experience as a forecast for their case.
Filing does not guarantee agreement, and the final terms may differ from those that were originally proposed. Nor does filing itself suspend examination or enforcement proceedings.[6] Outright rejection is nonetheless uncommon. Of the APA cases closed in 2025 by the United States and 13 of its principal treaty partners, 86% ended in agreement; most of the remainder were withdrawn or closed for other reasons; and fewer than 1% were rejected.
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER SIGNATURE
Signing an APA changes the tax department’s task rather than ending it. The taxpayer must apply the agreed method, make any required adjustments, maintain supporting records, and submit annual compliance reports. Critical assumptions, the facts and business conditions on which the agreement depends, also require continued attention. Before accepting terms, the department should identify who will own these tasks and whether its financial systems can support them.
PRESERVE A USEFUL PERIOD OF COVERAGE
New bilateral APAs completed in 2025 took a median of 46.4 months.[7] That historical figure is not a timetable for a new applicant, but it supports evaluating an APA before the next dispute consumes the tax department’s resources.
Timelines also depend on the treaty partner, and several partner programs moved faster in 2025. Germany’s average time to agreement fell from 54 months in 2024 to 39 in 2025; the United Kingdom’s fell from 53 to 44; and Germany, India, and France each granted more APAs than in 2023 or 2024 (Table 2).[8]
Table 2. APAs granted and applications filed: United States and principal treaty partners
|
|
APAs granted, 2023 |
APAs granted, 2024 |
APAs granted, 2025 |
Applications filed, 2025 |
Applications rejected, 2025 |
Average months to grant, 2025 |
|
United States |
132 |
129 |
96 |
155 |
2 |
44.9 |
|
India |
32 |
65 |
84 |
103 |
0 |
41.5 |
|
Japan |
164 |
139 |
161 |
171 |
0 |
41.6 |
|
Canada |
23 |
16 |
17 |
18 |
1 |
48.6 |
|
Germany |
46 |
58 |
78 |
83 |
1 |
38.9 |
|
Korea |
85 |
40 |
44 |
62 |
0 |
35.4 |
|
Ireland |
1 |
10 |
12 |
13 |
2 |
48.9 |
|
Switzerland |
75 |
66 |
83 |
90 |
0 |
28.9 |
|
United Kingdom |
15 |
27 |
26 |
20 |
0 |
43.9 |
|
France |
16 |
21 |
37 |
44 |
0 |
43.0 |
|
All 14 jurisdictions |
685 |
673 |
729 |
915 |
6 |
– |
Note: “All 14 jurisdictions” adds China, Denmark, Italy, and Mexico to the 10 shown.
The negotiation period need not consume all prospective coverage. Revenue Procedure 2015-41 provides that APMA typically seeks at least three prospective years when the underlying bilateral competent authority resolution is executed. Term extensions require coordination with the treaty partner.
Where appropriate, rollback may also extend the agreed approach to earlier years, subject to the relevant facts, procedural limits, and agreement of the authorities.[9] The APAs executed in 2025 carried an average term of six years, with 23% of them including rollback years.[10]
The assessment of whether to pursue an APA should not focus simply on how long an APA takes to negotiate. It should also weigh how much useful coverage the taxpayer expects to obtain, whether earlier years can be appropriately included, and whether the agreed approach will remain relevant to the business.
WHY RECURRING DISPUTES MATTER
Intragroup services involving intangibles and risk-control functions are receiving audit attention globally, and tax administrations can take different views of the same activities. For recurring transactions, resolving one audit cycle may still leave later years exposed. An APA offers an opportunity to address that recurring uncertainty rather than repeatedly defend the same pricing approach.
The mutual agreement procedure (MAP) is the treaty process through which competent authorities resolve cross-border tax disputes. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD’s) 2025 MAP statistics illustrate continuing dispute volumes, even as the OECD reported faster MAP resolution overall.
The number of transfer pricing MAP cases opened in the United States and 13 of its principal treaty partners rose from 1,299 in 2023 to 1,706 in 2025, an increase of 31%; the United States alone opened 163 in 2025, its highest total in five years.[11]
MAP generally addresses existing or anticipated taxation inconsistent with a treaty and may cover multiple taxable years. A bilateral APA, by contrast, provides an agreed framework for specified transactions that includes prospective years.
WHAT TAX DEPARTMENTS SHOULD DO NOW
- Identify suitable transactions. Map recurring flows by value, treaty partner, open years, and anticipated duration. Compare likely controversy exposure with application costs, internal resource demands, and continuing compliance obligations.
- Coordinate the request. Align the functional analysis, intercompany agreements, financial data, and positions taken in each jurisdiction. Address proposed rollback years and renewal timing as part of that assessment, rather than as separate exercises.
- Build for change. Consider how tariffs, restructurings, or changes in law could affect the proposed method and critical assumptions.
The final step is not necessarily an APA application. It is a focused assessment of recurring transactions: exposure, relevant jurisdictions, years needing coverage, expected business changes, and resources required to implement an agreement. That assessment should establish whether an APA is justified and what terms the business would need for an APA to be worthwhile.