LawFlash

Massachusetts SJC Requires Strict Compliance That ‘Employer’ Sign Noncompete

November 19, 2026
5 minute read

Key Takeaways

  • The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court requires that noncompete agreements subject to the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act be signed by the actual employing entity, not just the parent company.
  • Identifying a subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary is not a valid substitute for obtaining the employing entity’s signature on noncompete agreements.
  • Noncompete provisions in parent-level equity agreements will be unenforceable if the employing subsidiary does not sign, regardless of parent-subsidiary relationships.
  • Employers should promptly review and update all noncompete agreements to ensure compliance with the MNAA’s strict employer-signature requirement.

In Anaplan Parent, LP v. Brennan, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held that noncompetition covenants in the parent-company’s equity agreements were unenforceable because the subsidiary that employed the employee did not sign the agreements. The decision underscores the importance of obtaining the actual employing entity’s signature on agreements containing noncompetes subject to the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act—even when a parent company grants the equity supporting those restrictions.

On November 17, 2026, the court decided Anaplan Parent, LP v. Brennan, affirming the denial of preliminary injunctive relief to enforce noncompetition covenants against a subsidiary’s former employee.

The parent company’s signature did not satisfy the statute’s employer-signature requirement, and the subsidiary’s designation as a third-party beneficiary did not cure that omission.

BACKGROUND

Enacted in 2018, the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act (MNAA) establishes minimum requirements for covered noncompetition agreements to be valid and enforceable. Among those minimum requirements, an agreement must be in writing and signed by both the employer and employee.

Timothy Brennan worked for Anaplan, Inc., an enterprise software company. During his employment, he entered into equity incentive agreements with Anaplan Parent, LP, receiving equity interests in the parent in exchange for restrictive covenants, including a prohibition on competing with the subsidiary for 12 months after his employment ended. Brennan and the parent signed the agreements, but the employing subsidiary did not. The agreements expressly identified the subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary.

After Brennan accepted a position with a competitor, the parent and subsidiary sought a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. The Superior Court denied the requested relief because the agreements lacked the employing subsidiary’s signature, rendering the noncompetition covenants unenforceable under the MNAA.

THE COURT’S DECISION

In affirming the Superior Court’s decision, the Supreme Judicial Court rejected the argument that the parent qualified as Brennan’s employer merely because of its relationship with the subsidiary. Ordinarily, the employer is the entity for which the individual directly performs services. The record showed that Brennan performed services for the subsidiary, not the parent.

The court emphasized that affiliated entities cannot claim the benefits of corporate separateness, including the ordinary protection of a parent from liability as an employer, and then disregard that separateness to treat the parent’s signature as a substitute for the employing subsidiary’s signature on a noncompete.

The court also rejected the argument that the covenants fell within the MNAA’s exclusion for noncompetition agreements outside an employment relationship. While the parent was not Brennan’s employer, the restrictions arose from his employment with the subsidiary and limited his ability to compete with it after that employment ended: executing covenants with an affiliated entity rather than the employer did not place them outside the statute.

PARENT-LEVEL EQUITY DOES NOT ELIMINATE THE SIGNATURE REQUIREMENT

The Anaplan arrangement reflects a common business practice discussed in the amicus brief submitted by the US Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Massachusetts: equity compensation often is granted at the parent level because the parent maintains the equity plan and its shares provide the grant’s economic value.

Companies often include noncompete provisions in award agreements to satisfy the consideration requirement and because the noncompetes are intended to protect the confidential information, customer relationships, and goodwill of the subsidiaries.

Nevertheless, the court explained that the asserted tax consequences or partnership-law formalities did not excuse noncompliance with the employer-signature requirement. It also declined to excuse the missing signature based on the Anaplan entities’ contention that invalidating the noncompetes would give Brennan an inequitable windfall. The court reasoned that it could not disregard the employer-signature requirement because the legislature had made that requirement a condition of enforceability.

EMPLOYER CONSIDERATIONS

The MNAA’s requirements are some of the nation’s most stringent to navigate. In response, many employers take a layered approach of MNAA-compliant noncompete covenants as well as confidentiality and nonsolicitation restrictions (which are outside the scope of the MNAA) to protect their business interests. 

As equity plans have historically been issued in the name of the parent entity and the MNAA offered no guidance on this issue of interpretation, amici argued, unsuccessfully, that the court’s decision should apply prospectively only.

In the wake of this decision, employers should review agreements containing noncompetition provisions subject to the MNAA—including parent-level equity awards—to ensure that they satisfy all the statutory requirements, including that the employing entity signs the agreement along with the employee. Identifying the subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary is not a substitute for its signature.

This review should encompass existing agreements as well as templates and execution procedures for future equity awards. Any corrective steps should be evaluated in light of the MNAA’s applicable requirements, including notice and consideration.

As noted, the decision applies only to noncompetition covenants governed by the MNAA, not to every restriction contained in an equity agreement. The court did not address the enforceability of the other restrictive covenants in the Anaplan equity agreements, including the confidentiality, employee and customer nonsolicitation, and nondisparagement covenants.

HOW WE CAN HELP

Morgan Lewis lawyers regularly assist clients with reviewing and updating restrictive covenant agreements, evaluating enforceability under evolving state law, and developing strategies to protect trade secrets, other confidential information, customer and employee relationships, and goodwill. Our team can help identify affected agreements and evaluate potential corrective steps in light of the MNAA’s notice, consideration, and other applicable requirements.