LawFlash

More Fifth Circuit Judges Question the Constitutionality of the FCA’s Qui Tam Provisions

November 18, 2026
4 minute read

Key Takeaway

  • As the result of a recent decision, four Fifth Circuit judges have expressed serious Article II constitutional concerns with the FCA’s qui tam provisions and encouraged revisiting the Circuit’s prior precedent.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed government dismissal of a relator’s qui tam suit under the False Claims Act (FCA) in United States ex rel. Jackson v. United States on November 13, 2026. While the court’s application of the standard announced by the Supreme Court in Polansky is routine, two panel members cast additional doubt on the validity of the FCA’s qui tam provisions under Article II of the US Constitution and urged that the Circuit revisit its 25-year-old precedent.

Judge Don R. Willett, who wrote the majority opinion, also wrote a lengthy concurrence detailing serious Article II concerns with the FCA’s qui tam device. Chief Judge Jennifer Walker Elrod wrote briefly to endorse those concerns as “no doubt en banc worthy,” adding that “it may be time for our en banc court to revisit” the court’s 2001 en banc decision in Riley v. St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital, 252 F.3d 749 (5th Cir. 2001), upholding the qui tam provisions. Judges Elrod and Willet join fellow Fifth Circuit Judges Ho and Duncan who previously urged reexamination of this question in 2025 concurrences.[1]

BACKGROUND

The underlying qui tam action was brought by a former employee of Ventavia Research Group, which operated clinical trial sites for Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine. The relator asserted qui tam claims based on alleged protocol deviations and regulatory violations, along with a retaliation claim.

The government initially declined to intervene, after which the district court granted the defendants’ motions to dismiss with leave to amend. After the relator’s amendment, the government moved to intervene and dismiss the qui tam claims pursuant to 31 USC § 3730(c)(2)(a). The district court granted the motion, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed under the now familiar Polansky standard. It also affirmed the dismissal of the retaliation claim for failure to plead protected activity or Ventavia’s knowledge of it.

JUDGE WILLETT’S CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSIS

Although neither relator nor defendants raised the constitutionality of the qui tam provisions in the district court or on appeal, Judge Willett wrote separately to explain why the issue gives him “serious constitutional pause.” He grounded his concerns in the three provisions of Article II that have been the subject of recent challenges since Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas originally raised them in his dissenting opinion in Polansky: the Appointments Clause, the Vesting Clause, and the Take Care Clause.

Notably, Judge Willett acknowledged the Eleventh Circuit's recent rejection of an Appointments Clause challenge and characterized whether a relator occupies a continuing position established by law—a necessary condition to be considered an officer subject to appointment—a “closer question.” However, applying the same cases as the Eleventh Circuit, Judge Willett found the condition satisfied, reasoning that a relator who may litigate a single case for years holds something more than a temporary role.

Judge Willett described the Vesting and Take Care Clauses as presenting “a distinct—and stronger—problem.” In his view, more recent, post-Riley Supreme Court decisions preclude Congress from delegating enforcement power to private relators without appropriate supervision, which the FCA lacks.

In his concurrence, Judge Willet also refuted several standard defenses to the constitutionality of the FCA’s qui tam provisions:

  • Intervention Is Not Control: The government’s power to intervene and move to dismiss qui tam suits cannot qualify as the adequate control required by Supreme Court precedent because “control that must be reclaimed is not control.”
  • History Helps, But It Does Not Decide: Founding-era history and longstanding qui tam suit practice cannot preserve the FCA’s constitutionality because “pedigree is not permission.”
  • Assignment Explains the Claim, Not the Power: Treating the relator as an assignee may “transfer a claim” but cannot transfer executive authority.
  • Article IV Does Not Answer Article II: Congress’ control over “Property” mentioned in Article IV does not likely extend to every potential money claim the United States holds. And even if it does, it is unlikely that Congress may assign individuals to “litigate it in the United States’s name.”

CHIEF JUDGE ELROD’S CONCURRENCE

Chief Judge Elrod joined the majority opinion, but wrote separately to note that Judge Willett had “raised some serious constitutional concerns with qui tam litigation,” that those concerns “are no doubt en banc worthy,” and that “it may be time for our en banc court to revisit Riley.”

CONCLUSION

Should an en banc US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit revisit and overturn Riley, it would create a circuit split. Regardless, arguments that the qui tam provisions violate Article II remain pending in several other circuit and district courts, making it likely that the issue will reach the Supreme Court in the appropriate case.



[1] See United States ex rel. Gentry v. Encompass Health Rehab. Hosp. of Pearland, L.L.C., 157 F.4th 758, 766 (5th Cir. 2025) (Ho, J., concurring); United States ex rel. Montcrief v. Peripheral Vascular Assocs., P.A., 133 F.4th 395, 410–12 (5th Cir. 2025) (Duncan, J., concurring).