BLOG POST

Shifting Sands of Labor Law

YOUR SOURCE FOR MIDDLE EAST HR AND EMPLOYMENT LAW UPDATES

DIFC Court Confirms Employers Can Terminate on Notice Without Cause Despite Loss of Bonus Eligibility

In a recent judgment, Paget v Padresa [2026] DIFC CFI 045, the Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC) Court of First Instance confirmed that an employer may terminate an employee's employment on contractual notice, with or without giving a reason, even where the termination results in the employee losing eligibility for a substantial discretionary bonus.

Importantly, the court rejected the employee’s attempt to argue that the employer’s right to terminate should be subject to an implied obligation of good faith. The decision reinforces the importance of clear contractual drafting and provides reassurance to employers seeking to exercise their contractual termination rights.

Background: A Disputed Bonus of CHF 300,000

The employee was employed as a relationship manager at executive director level under an employment contract dated 21 June 2023. After the probationary period, either party could terminate the employment relationship by giving three months’ notice.

The employment contract expressly provided that variable compensation and bonus payments were discretionary and did not create any entitlement to future payments, even where bonuses had been awarded in successive years.

The contract also stipulated that bonus payments were conditional on neither party having given notice of termination before the relevant payment date. If employment had ended, or either party had given notice before that date, any pending bonus instalments would be forfeited, with no entitlement to a prorated payment.

Similar provisions appeared in the employer's handbook and variable compensation guidebook.

On 24 November 2025, the employer gave the employee three months’ notice, with employment terminating on 23 February 2026. The relevant bonus payment date fell after employment ended. The employee then brought proceedings seeking, among other things, approximately CHF 300,000 in discretionary bonus compensation.

The employer applied for immediate judgment on the bonus claim, arguing that the contractual conditions for payment were not satisfied.

Could the Employee Challenge the Reasons for Termination?

The employee argued that the employer’s contractual right to terminate on notice should be subject to an implied obligation to act in good faith. The employee therefore contended that the court should investigate the circumstances surrounding the termination to determine whether the employer had acted in good faith. The employee argued that factual disputes concerning the reasons for termination required a full trial.

The court rejected that argument. H.E. Justice Mark Pelling held that the employer had an unqualified contractual right to terminate employment on three months’ notice. That right was also consistent with Article 62 of DIFC Employment Law No. 2 of 2019, as amended, which expressly permits employers and employees to terminate employment without cause, subject to the applicable notice requirements.

H.E. Justice Pelling stated, “In my judgment, it is beyond argument that the Defendant was entitled to serve notice for any or no reason and thus the need for an investigation of whether or not there was a legitimate reason for terminating the contract is simply one that does not arise.”

The court explained that where an employer has an unqualified right to terminate employment on notice, it is not necessary to establish a legitimate business reason for exercising that right. The employee’s attempt to introduce an implied good faith qualification under Article 57 of the DIFC Contract Law was unsuccessful. In reaching that conclusion, the court relied on established DIFC Court of Appeal authorities, including Lutfi v DIFCA and Al Herz v DIFCA, which emphasise the primacy of express contractual termination provisions and the statutory framework governing DIFC employment relationships.

What Did This Mean for the Employee’s Bonus?

Having found that the employer was entitled to terminate employment without cause, the court turned to the contractual bonus provisions. Those provisions expressly required the employee to remain eligible for payment, including by not being under notice of termination on the relevant payment date. Because notice had been given before the bonus payment date and the employment relationship had ended before that date, the contractual conditions for payment were not satisfied. The court therefore concluded that the employee had no entitlement to the discretionary bonus or even to be considered for an award. Importantly, the employee could not circumvent the express contractual conditions by arguing that the employer should not have terminated employment when it did.

The court granted immediate judgment in the employer’s favour, dismissing the bonus claim without requiring a full trial.

What Does This Mean for DIFC Employers?

Article 62 of the DIFC Employment Law expressly permits termination without cause, subject to the applicable notice requirements. The judgment indicates that an employee cannot ordinarily challenge an otherwise valid exercise of an unqualified contractual termination right simply by arguing that the employer lacked a legitimate reason or acted without good faith.  However, this does not remove the need to comply with other applicable statutory protections, including those relating to discrimination and victimisation, or any additional contractual obligations.

The outcome depended heavily on the wording of the employment contract. The employer had expressly stated that bonuses were discretionary and that entitlement was conditional on neither party having given notice of termination before the payment date. Employers should ensure that bonus arrangements clearly address eligibility, payment dates, the effect of resignation or dismissal, and whether any prorated entitlement arises where employment ends before payment. In addition, the relevant bonus conditions appeared not only in the employment contract but also in the employer's handbook and variable compensation guidebook. That consistency supported the contractual framework governing bonus eligibility. Employers should review their employment contracts, bonus plans, incentive policies, and employee handbooks to ensure that the provisions are aligned and do not inadvertently create conflicting entitlements.

The decision underscores the importance of clear, consistent employment documentation when managing terminations and discretionary bonus arrangements.