The proposed amendments would significantly reshape public companies’ compensation reporting obligations, potentially reducing disclosure and compliance burdens; however, the proposed amendments would also introduce new compensation measurements, non-GAAP disclosures, and data-tagging requirements.
If adopted, the amendments would require companies to reassess their disclosure practices, compensation data collection processes, and reporting systems.
NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS WOULD GENERALLY BE LIMITED TO CEO & CFO
The proposal redefines named executive officers (NEOs) to include only the individuals who served as the principal executive officer (PEO) (i.e., the chief executive officer (CEO)) or principal financial officer (PFO) (i.e., the chief financial officer (CFO)), or performed similar functions, at any time during the last completed fiscal year.
For larger companies, this generally would reduce the typical NEO population from five individuals to two. The same approach would apply to smaller reporting companies (SRCs) and emerging growth companies (EGCs), which currently are only required to provide compensation information for three NEOs (i.e., the PEO and the next two most highly compensated executive officers).
Importantly, the proposal would not cap the number of NEOs at two persons: companies with leadership transitions, interim officers, or co-CEOs could still have more than two NEOs as, consistent with the current rules, each individual who served as the PEO or PFO at any point during the fiscal year would qualify as an NEO.
The narrower NEO definition would also affect certain Form 8-K reporting obligations that depend on NEO status. However, Item 5.02(b) would continue to require departure disclosures for other expressly covered officers, including the president, principal accounting officer, and principal operating officer. Similarly, Item 5.02(c) would continue to require disclosure of appointments to specified officer positions, including the president, principal financial officer, principal accounting officer, and principal operating officer, regardless of whether the individual qualifies as an NEO.
Item 5.02(e) would also continue to apply to material compensatory arrangements involving the principal executive officer, principal financial officer, or other NEOs, however, the narrower NEO definition would reduce the population of executives whose compensatory arrangements trigger disclosure solely by virtue of their NEO status.
The $1 million deduction limitation under Section 162(m) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the Code), for compensation paid to a public company’s “covered employees” continues to apply to the company’s CEO, CFO, and the company’s three highest paid executive officers for the taxable year (other than the CEO or CFO), among others. Companies will need to continue to calculate the annual compensation for those individuals under Section 162(m) even if the compensation no longer must be disclosed.
Practice Tip: Although many disclosure requirements will be reduced commiserate with the reduction in the number of NEOs, other regulatory requirements will continue to apply that necessitate ongoing monitoring of compensation decisions and awards for all officers, such as Section 16 filings and compliance with Section 162(m) for “covered employees.”
THREE NEW TABLES WOULD REPLACE THE EXISTING TABULAR DISCLOSURE FRAMEWORK
The SEC would replace the existing Summary Compensation Table, the Grants of Plan-Based Awards, Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End, and Option Exercises and Stock Vested tables with three new tables designed to distinguish compensation opportunities from compensation actually earned or realized.
The separate Pension Benefits and Nonqualified Deferred Compensation tables would be eliminated, with specified retirement-related amounts instead reported in the new Earned Compensation Table.
Earned Compensation Table. The Earned Compensation Table would report salary earned, non-equity incentive awards earned, amounts realized upon the vesting of stock awards and exercise of stock options, and other compensation, including reportable perquisites and retirement-related amounts. By focusing on compensation actually earned or realized during the fiscal year, the table could include earned or realized amounts attributable to equity awards granted in prior years.
Granted Compensation Table. The Granted Compensation Table would report annualized base salary, non-equity incentive awards, and stock and option awards granted during the fiscal year, providing a separate view of the compensation opportunities awarded to executives during the fiscal year. Equity awards would continue to be valued under Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification Topic 718, but using target performance outcomes rather than the probable outcomes generally used to value awards subject to performance conditions under the current disclosure framework. As a result, reported values could differ from amounts used in the company’s financial statements.
In an implicit acknowledgment of public companies’ typical governance timing and cadence, companies could elect to attribute equity awards granted during the first quarter of a fiscal year to the preceding fiscal year if the company determines that the awards relate to performance in that preceding year. Companies making this election would be required to apply the approach consistently across the reporting periods presented and disclose the methodology used.
Status of Equity Awards Table. The Status of Equity Awards Table would provide award-level information about outstanding equity awards and their subsequent vesting, exercise, or other disposition, linking the compensation opportunities reported in the Granted Compensation Table to the amounts ultimately reflected in the Earned Compensation Table. It would consolidate information about award terms and status without requiring companies to recalculate outstanding awards annually.
Practice Tip: Companies should assess whether their existing compensation data and reporting systems can support the proposed tables rather than assuming that current disclosures can simply be reformatted. Particular attention should be given to the timing and award of equity grants, tracking of vesting and exercise events, valuation of performance-based awards using target outcomes, and reconciliation of awards granted in one fiscal year but earned or realized in another.
PERQUISITE DISCLOSURE WOULD BECOME MORE FLEXIBLE
The proposal increases the annual aggregate perquisite reporting threshold from $10,000 to $150,000 for each NEO. It would also permit companies to exclude individual benefits qualifying as de minimis fringe benefits under Section 132(a)(4) of the Code when determining whether the aggregate threshold has been reached. Although the exclusion would reduce tracking requirements for qualifying benefits, companies would still need to identify and assess other potential perquisites to determine whether the higher aggregate threshold is exceeded.
The SEC would also revise its interpretive guidance to give companies greater discretion to determine whether a benefit is integrally and directly related to a NEO’s duties, provided the determination is reasonable and made in good faith.
The release explains that, under the proposed approach, a company could conclude that continuous personal security services or required use of company aircraft for personal travel due to security concerns is directly related to a NEO’s duties and therefore not a perquisite. This would be a facts-and-circumstances determination, not a categorical exemption.
Separately, the proposal would eliminate the requirement to value perquisites using aggregate incremental cost, allowing greater flexibility in valuation, including avoiding separate valuations solely for SEC disclosure purposes where appropriate.
Practice Tip: Companies should preserve documentation supporting the business rationale for executive security and other benefits, the basis for any classification decision, and the valuation methodology used. Companies should also review their perquisite identification and tracking procedures to assess how the proposed threshold, classification guidance, and valuation flexibility could affect their disclosure processes. The proposed flexibility should not be treated as permission to stop reviewing benefits or to change current reporting practices before the amendments become effective.
CD&A WOULD BE STREAMLINED AND MODIFY HOW COMPANIES DISCLOSE THE USE OF NON-GAAP FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE MEASURES
Under the proposed amendments, the Compensation Discussion and Analysis (CD&A) requirement would be revised to focus on three topics: the compensation program’s objectives in relation to corporate strategy, the material compensation elements and how their amounts are determined, and, where applicable, whether and how the most recent say-on-pay vote affected compensation policies and decisions. The SEC would eliminate the existing list of illustrative discussion topics while retaining the need for company-specific disclosure of material information.
With respect to the use and disclosure of non-GAAP financial performance measures as incentive compensation targets, the proposal retains the existing exemption from Regulation G and Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K but introduces additional disclosure requirements for non-GAAP measures disclosed under Item 402.
Non-GAAP measures based on historical financial results would require a quantitative reconciliation to the most directly comparable GAAP measure. Projection-based targets would require a narrative explanation of how the measure is calculated from the company’s audited financial statements; the existing accommodation to omit target levels if disclosure would cause competitive harm would be unchanged. Companies would also have to explain why the non-GAAP measure is more appropriate than a GAAP measure for the relevant compensation or performance assessment.
Practice Tip: Companies that use non-GAAP measures in their incentive compensation programs should involve financial reporting personnel in evaluating the proposal’s impact. While the streamlined CD&A may alleviate some administrative burden, the reconciliation of non-GAAP measures and explanation of projected targets and why non-GAAP measures are appropriate for compensation purposes will require careful coordination between HR, legal, and financial reporting.
PAY-VERSUS-PERFORMANCE & PAY RATIO DISCLOSURES SIMPLIFIED, BUT NOT ELIMINATED
Pay-Versus-Performance. The proposal would replace the specialized Compensation Actually Paid calculation with the total reported in the Earned Compensation Table. Disclosure would cover the PEO and PFO individually over three fiscal years, rather than the current five-year period generally applicable to larger companies, and eliminate the current requirement to report average compensation for other NEOs, as is currently the case.
The company’s cumulative total shareholder return (TSR) would become the sole required performance measure. Required net income and peer-group TSR disclosures, along with the tabular list of performance measures, would be eliminated. Companies could elect to disclose additional company-selected financial performance measures.
Pay Ratio. The proposal limits the employee population used to identify the median employee to full-time employees in the United States and its territories, excluding seasonal and temporary employees and internationally based employees. Under the current rules, companies are permitted to use the same median employee for up to three fiscal years provided that there has not been a material change to the company’s employee population. The proposal would extend the median-employee identification cycle from three years to five years and use the Granted Compensation Table methodology to determine annual total compensation for the PEO and median employee.
The distinction between the two proposed compensation measures is important: pay-versus-performance would use earned compensation, while pay ratio would use granted compensation. The five-year identification cycle would not replace annual pay ratio reporting with a five-year reporting requirement.
Practice Tip: Companies should model the potential effects of both the revised employee population and compensation methodology on their reported pay ratios and pay-versus-performance disclosures. Changes in the reported pay ratio or pay-versus-performance presentation could reflect the new rules rather than changes in compensation practices, requiring the company to provide an explanation of the impact of the rule changes.
CLAWBACK DISCLOSURE ELIMINATION WOULD NOT CHANGE RECOVERY OBLIGATIONS
The proposal would eliminate both financial statement error-correction checkboxes on the cover pages of Forms 10-K, 20-F, and 40-F. It would also remove the requirement to explain why a restatement did not require compensation recovery and simplify disclosure of amounts for which recovery was determined to be impracticable, including eliminating certain NEO-by-NEO breakdowns.
The proposed changes would reduce disclosure obligations without altering the underlying clawback policy and recovery requirements, which remain required by applicable listing standards of national securities exchanges. In this respect, the SEC expressly states that amendments to Rule 10D-1 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (Exchange Act), including how and when recovery policies apply, are outside the proposal’s scope.
Practice Tip: Since the proposal would only alleviate the limited disclosure requirements associated with clawback recovery, companies should maintain continued compliance with applicable listing requirements and obligations to maintain and apply required clawback policies.
TERMINATION AND GOLDEN PARACHUTE DISCLOSURES WOULD BE REVISED
The proposal would eliminate the prescriptive requirement to quantify hypothetical payments under various termination and change-in-control scenarios. Companies instead would be required to simply provide narrative disclosure describing the material terms of written and unwritten arrangements that provide payments or benefits in those circumstances for their NEOs, as is currently the case.
Transaction-related golden parachute disclosure would remain, but its presentation would be streamlined. The proposal would retain cash and equity categories, consolidate other material compensation into a miscellaneous category, and retain an aggregate total. The revised NEO definition would also narrow the individuals covered by these disclosures.
Practice Tip: Transaction teams should not conflate elimination of hypothetical annual severance calculations with elimination of transaction-specific golden parachute disclosure. Companies should continue maintaining records sufficient to evaluate contractual entitlements and quantify payments in an actual transaction.
DIRECTOR COMPENSATION DISCLOSURE WOULD ALLOW FLEXIBLE PRESENTATION
Companies would no longer be required to present the prescribed Director Compensation Table. Instead, they could present the required information through narrative disclosure, tables, or a combination thereof, while continuing to quantify compensation for each individual who served as a director during the fiscal year and describe the material aspects of the company’s director compensation program.
The proposal would also change the measurement of director equity compensation. Rather than reporting the grant date fair value of director equity awards, companies would report the amounts realized upon stock award vesting and exercise of stock options, consistent with the proposed Earned Compensation Table approach for NEOs.
FURTHER CHANGES WOULD AFFECT SMALLER REPORTING COMPANIES, DATA TAGGING REQUIREMENTS & REGISTRATION STATEMENTS
Scaled Disclosure. SRCs and EGCs would retain two-year reporting periods for both the Earned Compensation Table and Granted Compensation Table and remain exempt from CD&A and pay ratio disclosure. SRCs and EGCs would nevertheless be required to provide all three new primary tables. EGCs would continue to be exempt from pay-versus-performance and golden parachute compensation disclosure.
Inline XBRL. Large accelerated filers would be required to tag the information in the three new primary compensation tables. Footnotes and other narrative compensation disclosures would not be subject to the new tagging requirement. The existing tagging requirements for pay-versus-performance and clawback disclosures would be eliminated.
Eliminated Disclosure Items. The SEC would eliminate the standalone disclosure requirements concerning compensation policies and practices related to risk management under current Item 402(s) and equity award grants close in time to the release of material nonpublic information under the recently enacted Item 402(x).
Registration Statement Timing. The proposed amendments would relieve the considerable timing pressure associated with certain registered offerings shortly after fiscal year-end by providing companies using specified long-form registration statements (such as Forms S-1, S-4, and S-11) additional time to provide compensation disclosure for the most recently completed fiscal year. Under the proposal, the information would be due by the earlier of its disclosure in another specified Exchange Act filing or 120 days after fiscal year-end, which aligns with the timing available for short-form registration statements (e.g., Form S-3). A pre-effective amendment would be required when the registration statement becomes effective after the applicable disclosure deadline.
TIMING AND PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Acknowledging the significant preparation and implementation effort that the proposed rules would require of public companies if adopted, the SEC proposes that the final rules, if adopted, would not become effective until January 1 of the calendar year following publication of the adopting release in the Federal Register.
Mandatory compliance would begin with a company’s first full fiscal year ending on or after that effective date. Companies would be required to apply the final rules in any registration statement or prospectus that is required to include financial statements for a fiscal year ending on or after the effective date when initially filed. The release gives the example of an adopting release published during 2027, resulting in a January 1, 2028 effective date. For a calendar-year company, that framework would generally mean mandatory application to fiscal year 2028 compensation disclosure included in a registration statement, prospectus, or proxy statement filed in 2029 with the exact timing governed by the nature of the specific filing.
Companies could elect to comply earlier, but only after the effective date and only by providing disclosure responsive to the amended item in its entirety. The SEC is also requesting comment on whether additional transition or phase-in provisions are necessary.
For now, companies should continue applying the existing requirements while assessing the potential impacts of the proposal. The immediate priorities should be identifying data gaps, evaluating how the new measurement approaches would affect reported compensation, and planning for any practical and operational hurdles. Public companies should also consider their investor base and the expectations, if any, that certain investors and advisory firms may have with respect to executive compensation disclosures.
Companies should also approach any future reduction in disclosure deliberately. In line with the bedrock of the federal securities laws, the proposal would retain an overarching materiality-based framework, including disclosure necessary to understand the new compensation tables. Eliminating a prescriptive disclosure requirement would not necessarily eliminate the need to disclose the underlying information if it remains material to investors’ understanding of executive compensation. Furthermore, other regulatory requirements may require continued monitoring of compensation made to non-NEOs, such as Section 16 filings made on behalf of officers and directors and Section 162(m) compliance.
Finally, companies should consider whether formal SEC engagement on the proposal is warranted, including through the public comment process. The comment period will close 60 days after publication of the proposing release in the Federal Register.